The Milk War: Oat vs. Almond vs. Soy vs. Milk

The Great Milk Swap: Healthier Choice or Better Marketing?

It’s official: we’re in the golden age of milk alternatives. Walk into any café or grocery store, and you’ll see oat, almond, soy, cashew, coconut, pea, hemp, and even potato milk—lined up like trendy accessories. Non-dairy milk isn’t just a product anymore. It’s a lifestyle choice, a social signal, and in some cases, a carefully marketed illusion of health and sustainability.

But when you strip away the branding, how different are these milks from each other—or from traditional dairy, for that matter? Are we actually making better choices, or just different ones with better packaging?

Let’s take a closer look….

Oat Milk: The Creamy Illusion

Oat milk has taken the lead in recent years, especially in cafés where texture and foamability matter. According to Nielsen data, U.S. sales of oat milk have surged by over 50% year-over-year, making it the fastest-growing plant-based milk on the market. It’s now found in more than 30% of coffee shops, and brands like Oatly, Califia, and Minor Figures have built their entire identities around cozy vibes and clever copy.

On the surface, oat milk feels like the perfect alternative. Oats are relatively eco-friendly—they require 80% less water than almonds, grow widely without relying on pollination, and carry none of the baggage of industrial dairy. That’s made oat milk a poster child for sustainability.

But when you flip the carton, the story gets more complicated.

To mimic the creaminess of dairy, many manufacturers add canola oil, gellan gum, enzymes, and in some cases, added sugar. That natural sweetness you taste? It’s often the result of enzymatic processing that converts oat starch into simple sugars not something oats do on their own.

It’s smooth. It’s satisfying. It plays incredibly well with espresso. But nutritionally? It’s a bit of a mirage….comforting, familiar, and cleverly branded, but highly processed and often lacking real value beyond mouthfeel.

Almond Milk: Mostly Water, Very Marketable

Almond milk is still the reigning champ in grocery store shelves, accounting for about 59% of plant-based milk sales in the U.S. according to SPINS data. It’s often seen as the “light” or “low-cal” option, and it’s been riding the health halo of almonds for years.

But here’s the reality: most commercial almond milks contain only 2% almonds. The rest? Mostly water, some added vitamins, a few emulsifiers, and sometimes a touch of sugar to smooth out the taste. Nutritionally, it’s thin—30 to 60 calories per cup, often with less than 1 gram of protein, and not much else unless it’s fortified.

And then there’s the water issue. Almonds are notoriously thirsty crops. It takes around 1.1 gallons (4.2 liters) of water to grow a single almond, and an 8-ounce glass of almond milk can use over 70 liters of water in its production. Nearly all U.S. almonds come from California—a region where water scarcity isn’t just an issue, it’s a crisis.

So yes, almond milk might be lower in calories. But environmentally and nutritionally, it’s arguably one of the weakest choices…despite its longstanding health reputation.

Soy Milk: The Old School Hero

Before the alt-milk boom, there was soy. And despite the noise surrounding newer options, soy milk remains one of the only plant-based alternatives that truly stands up to dairy from a nutritional standpoint.

One cup of soy milk typically contains 7 to 9 grams of protein, along with healthy fats, isoflavones, and naturally occurring potassium, calcium, and iron. Nutritionally, it’s one of the most complete non-dairy options out there—far closer to dairy than almond or oat.

So why did it fall out of fashion? Blame it on perception. Soy was sidelined by persistent myths about phytoestrogens plant compounds that mimic estrogen in the body and widespread concerns about GMOs. Moderate soy consumption is safe and many soy products today are made with non-GMO soybeans or labeled accordingly.

Even so, soy isn’t perfect….especially in the cafe. While it holds up well in cold drinks and has a relatively neutral taste, it can be temperamental to steam. Baristas often struggle with curdling or inconsistent texture, particularly in acidic espresso-based drinks. It’s not the most reliable performer behind the bar, and that’s part of why it’s fallen out of favor.

It may lack the trendy branding or frothability of oat, but if you’re prioritizing protein and nutrition, soy still quietly outperforms most of its alt-milk peers—just maybe not in your flat white.

And What About Dairy?

In the rush to ditch cow’s milk, we may have overlooked a key truth: dairy milk still delivers on what most people expect milk to do—nutritionally and functionally.

A single cup of whole milk contains 8 grams of complete protein, plus naturally occurring calcium, potassium, B12, and healthy fats that support nutrient absorption. Unlike most alternatives, it doesn’t need to be fortified to meet those benchmarks. It’s a single-ingredient, whole food—no added sugar, no stabilizers, no oils. And for all the imitators out there, dairy is still the gold standard when it comes to texture, consistency, and performance in coffee.

Of course, dairy isn’t without its problems. Industrial farming, methane emissions, land use, and animal welfare are legitimate concerns—and they’ve rightfully fueled the demand for alternatives. But it’s worth noting: not all dairy is created equal. Small-scale, pasture-based, and regenerative dairy farms are gaining traction, aiming to do things differently and more responsibly.

And for those who choose it, dairy remains one of the most nutrient-dense, minimally processed options in the entire milk aisle.

In the shift toward alternatives, we replaced a natural product with complex formulations—and often never questioned the trade-off. Milk isn’t trendy, but it still holds up.

Final Pour

The non-dairy milk boom is here to stay. But we can’t keep pretending that alt-milk automatically means “healthier,” “cleaner,” or “more sustainable.” Most of these products are ultra-processed, low in protein, and engineered to behave like something they’re not.

Marketing has done a brilliant job—packaging up convenience, lifestyle, and perceived wellness into one neatly branded carton. But the reality is: many consumers are buying based on buzzwords, barista culture, and vibes—not facts.

Alt-milks have their place, but let’s not lose sight of what’s actually in the cup. Taste, texture, nutrition, and sustainability all matter but no one milk nails them all. And once you strip away the storytelling, what you’re left with is a choice that should be made with a little more clarity—and a lot less spin.

Trends will change. Packaging will evolve. But one thing won’t: the importance of flipping the carton, reading the ingredients, and asking better questions about what we drink every single day.

That’s not trendy. That’s just smart.

The Business of Being "Better Than Milk"

The global plant-based milk market is currently valued at over $20 billion USD, and it's projected to reach $35–40 billion by 2030, according to data from Grand View Research and Fortune Business Insights.

While the U.S. remains one of the largest markets (with almond, oat, and soy leading the pack), the category is expanding rapidly in Europe, China, and Southeast Asia.

Almond milk still holds the largest global share, but oat milk is the fastest-growing segment, especially in cafes and premium grocery channels. The category now makes up 15–20% of the entire milk market in some developed countries—and continues to climb, driven by health trends, dairy intolerance, and climate-conscious consumer behavior out coffee they’re about how we approach craft, community, and curiosity.

Alt Milk is BIG BUSINESS

Reading: In Tokyo, Exploring The Flavors Of Coffee Omakase (Sprudge) – A beautifully written deep dive into Tokyo’s emerging coffee omakase culture. Less latte art more sensory storytelling. If you’ve ever wanted to experience coffee like a 10-course tasting menu, this one’s for you!

Watching: Turn off your phone/TV and go outside.

Listening: While outside..listen :)

Brewing: Went with a Rao spin this morning on the V60—20g of coffee to 300g water at 96°C, with a slightly finer grind than usual (think medium-fine, close to table salt). Bloomed with 60g, gave it a solid swirl, then poured to 150g at 40 seconds and swirled again. Finished the pour to 300g with no bypass, and spun the dripper at the end to flatten the bed. Brew wrapped up right around 2:30. Result? Clean, juicy, and weirdly balanced.

respond with a photo of your brew bar or get creative with an AI generated scene and we’ll feature and share in an upcoming week of BTD

Distance: Buy the Drip run club. Clocking some kilometers. Help us push a few more kilometers through this week?

Want to join us as we hit the road? Let’s connect on Strava! or, join our Whoop group - just respond to the email and let’s grind together!